When Gifting Goes Wrong: The Beauty of Imperfect Giving

A year ago, I got a very dear friend this cute shirt for his birthday. I beamed with excitement as I watched him unwrap his gift; I was so certain he would love it. It's totally his style!. The silence that followed barely a minute later isn't something I was prepared for. The shirt was a size too small, with loose threads here and there. I had the vendor deliver the shirt to his residence directly, so I didn't get the chance to see it beforehand. Boy! Was I embarrassed? 🤧. I still cringe whenever that moment crosses my mind. We laugh about it today, but I wanted to disappear in that moment. I had a huge crush on this guy! Of course it was embarrassing.

Unfortunately, this happens way more than you think—moments when a gift completely misses the mark. You hand it over with a smile, excitement bubbling in your chest, already picturing the delighted expression that will light up their face. They start to unwrap it, and for a moment, everything feels right. Then comes that pause. The one where they blink, tilt their head, and say something like, “Oh… this is… interesting.” And in that single word, your heart sinks.

We’ve all been there.  The perfume you thought was elegant made them sneeze for an hour. It happens to the best of us. In fact, the more we care, the more likely we are to get it wrong sometimes. Because giving is an emotional act, not a logical one.

And that, oddly enough, is where the beauty of it lies.

We like to think of the perfect gift as a reflection of how well we know someone. We want it to say, “I see you. I get you. You matter to me.” So we analyze, overthink, and sometimes spiral into the world of online reviews, trying to decode what would make the other person feel most loved.

But in chasing perfection, we forget something important; the act of giving is already the gift.

Think about the gifts you remember most.

Not the objectively perfect ones, but the ones that made you laugh or told a story. Maybe it was the pair of pants your cousin gave you that immediately turned into a skirt the moment you put it on because it was too tight. Or the time your partner tried to surprise you with a kitchen gadget you never asked for, but it broke on day two. You probably didn’t keep all of them, but you definitely remember them.

Those imperfect gifts stick with us because they remind us that giving is an act of vulnerability. When you give someone a gift, you are saying, in your imperfect way, “I thought of you. I wanted to make you happy.” This opens the door to disappointment. But it also opens the door to connection, to laughter, and to stories that will be told for years.

I once received a gift that still makes me smile, though at the time, I didn’t know how to react. It was lingerie, but my boobs could barely fit into the cups. I smiled awkwardly, said thank you, and tucked it away. A few months later, I regifted it, but the memories of that day still bring a smile to my face.

That’s the quiet magic of imperfect giving.  Sometimes it shows us how to laugh at our expectations. And sometimes, it’s just a reminder that even the most thoughtful people get it wrong, and that’s perfectly okay.

There’s also a certain honesty in gifts that go wrong. They strip away the polished idea that everything in relationships has to be just right. They remind us that affection isn’t measured by precision. A “wrong” gift can even deepen a relationship because it invites authenticity.

Truth is, our intentions don’t always translate perfectly. Maybe you were thinking of their love for chocolate cakes, not realizing they just switched to red velvet cakes. Or maybe you thought they’d appreciate something sentimental when they actually prefer the practical. But even when the translation is clumsy, the intention still shines through.

Weirdly, receiving imperfect gifts also makes us better. It teaches patience and empathy. It nudges us to look past the object and see the effort. Sometimes, it even shows us the different ways people express love. For one person, it’s buying something fancy. For another, it’s making something by hand. For someone else, it’s giving something they themselves love, hoping you’ll love it too. When we learn to receive with grace, even when the gift isn’t what we expected, we become softer, kinder, more open.

The truth is, there will always be gifts that don’t quite land. You’ll give something you think is perfect and watch it fall flat. You’ll receive something that makes you wonder if the giver knows you at all. But if you zoom out a little, you’ll see that these moments are part of a bigger picture — one where people keep trying to connect, to celebrate, to bring each other joy. Imperfect gifts are simply proof that we’re still trying.

The beauty of giving lies not in the flawless execution but in the willingness to show up with a token of thoughtfulness and hope it lands somewhere near the heart.

So the next time you find yourself holding a gift that didn’t quite work out, try not to cringe. Laugh a little. Tell the story, but remember the thought behind it. Because there’s something profoundly human about imperfection. A wrong gift might not look like much, but it often carries the most honest kind of love.

On the other hand, I do know the best way to ensure you never receive a wrong gift 🤭—creating a gift registry with SincerelyYoursNg. Creating a gift registry can be likened to walking into a gift shop with a loved one and getting to pick out your gift yourself. How exciting! 😁.

You should definitely visit www.Sincerelyyours.com.ng to curate your personalized wishlist today.